Connect with us

Accounting

IRS agrees to share tax data on immigrants for criminal cases

Published

on

The Internal Revenue Service will give taxpayer data about immigrants to U.S. authorities conducting criminal investigations, saying it will support President Donald Trump’s pledge to deport people illegally in the U.S.  

A memorandum of understanding was struck Monday between the Treasury Department, which oversees the IRS, and the Department of Homeland Security to share information in response to valid law enforcement requests. The agreement was part of documents filed over a lawsuit by four immigration groups seeking to slow the Trump administration’s mass deportation policies.

The groups sued to block the IRS from potentially sharing taxpayer information about millions of non-citizens who don’t have Social Security numbers but may pay taxes after obtaining Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers. While federal officials say the agreement includes safeguards and applies only to criminal matters, immigrant and tax groups warn that the IRS shouldn’t reverse longstanding privacy policies to target migrants.

“The MOU only permits the lawful exchange of information for taxpayers who are under criminal investigation or subject to a criminal proceeding,” the Justice Department’s tax division said in a court filing. That agreement “simply establishes procedures and guardrails for ensuring that such requests and subsequent transfers of information are handled lawfully and securely.”

Being in the country without authorization is not a crime by itself, but the Trump administration has referred to those crossing the border illegally as criminals and has enlisted the IRS in its crackdown.

Access to sensitive tax data would “expose millions of taxpayers to the administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement tactics,” the groups, including Centro de Trabajadores Unidos, said in the complaint. The IRS’s computer systems “house the single largest source of the names and current addresses of individuals not authorized to be present in the United States.” 

A spokesperson for the Treasury said that the agreement establishes a “clear and secure process to support law enforcement’s efforts to combat illegal immigration.”

“The bases for this MOU are founded in longstanding authorities granted by Congress, which serve to protect the privacy of law-abiding Americans while streamlining the ability to pursue criminals,” the spokesperson said.

The Tax Law Center at the New York University School of Law said in a report last week that an IRS-Homeland Security data-sharing agreement could erode voluntary tax compliance, a key to the U.S. tax system. It may deter people from filing taxes out of fear of immigration enforcement, even in error, potentially costing billions in lost revenue. The move also breaks decades of IRS assurances that immigrants’ tax data would remain confidential.

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem signed the agreement, which allows for sharing tax information for crimes related to migration. One involves aliens who willfully stay in the U.S. for 90 days after a removal order and another involves immigrants who reenter the U.S. after a removal order, according to the memo and the court filing. 

The groups that filed the lawsuit also include Immigrant Solidarity DuPage, Somos Un Pueblo Unido and Inclusive Action for the City. They said that a section of the Internal Revenue Code, known as 6103, forbids the Treasury Department from sharing return information for civil immigration enforcement.

“All the evidence suggests DHS wants this information to find undocumented workers, and that’s not a permissible basis for sharing confidential taxpayer information,” said Nandan Joshi, a lawyer for the plaintiffs with Public Citizen. “The only way to get confidential information to locate potential criminals is to get a court order.”

They are seeking a preliminary injunction to prevent the IRS from transferring the data until the court issues a final decision. U.S. District Judge Dabney Friedrich previously denied their request for a temporary block in Washington federal court. 

Section 6103 of the Tax Code allows sharing information in criminal investigations and proceedings. In 2017, the complaint says, the IRS said the code didn’t permit it to share tax data with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. 

“To entertain and enter into an information sharing agreement,” the IRS “would have to change its interpretation of section 6103” and provide “a reasoned explanation for that change,” the groups said in their complaint. 

A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson said that the government is “sharing information across the federal government to solve problems.”

“Information sharing across agencies is essential to identify who is in our country, including violent criminals, determine what public safety and terror threats may exist so we can neutralize them, scrub these individuals from voter rolls, as well as identify what public benefits these aliens are using at taxpayer expense,” the spokesperson said.

The case is Centro de Trabajadores Unidos v. Bessent, 25-cv-677, US District Court (District of Columbia).

— With assistance from Daniel Flatley, Zoe Tillman, Hadriana Lowenkron and Alicia A. Caldwell

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Accounting

Acting IRS commissioner reportedly replaced

Published

on

Gary Shapley, who was named only days ago as the acting commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service, is reportedly being replaced by Deputy Treasury Secretary Michael Faulkender amid a power struggle between Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Elon Musk.

The New York Times reported that Bessent was outraged that Shapley was named to head the IRS without his knowledge or approval and complained to President Trump about it. Shapley was installed as acting commissioner on Tuesday, only to be ousted on Friday. He first gained prominence as an IRS Criminal Investigation special agent and whistleblower who testified in 2023 before the House Oversight Committee that then-President Joe Biden’s son Hunter received preferential treatment during a tax-evasion investigation, and he and another special agent had been removed from the investigation after complaining to their supervisors in 2022. He was promoted last month to senior advisor to Bessent and made deputy chief of IRS Criminal Investigation. Shapley is expected to remain now as a senior official at IRS Criminal Investigation, according to the Wall Street Journal. The IRS and the Treasury Department press offices did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Faulkender was confirmed last month as deputy secretary at the Treasury Department and formerly worked during the first Trump administration at the Treasury on the Paycheck Protection Program before leaving to teach finance at the University of Maryland.

Faulkender will be the fifth head of the IRS this year. Former IRS commissioner Danny Werfel departed in January, on Inauguration Day, after Trump announced in December he planned to name former Congressman Billy Long, R-Missouri, as the next IRS commissioner, even though Werfel’s term wasn’t scheduled to end until November 2027. The Senate has not yet scheduled a confirmation hearing for Long, amid questions from Senate Democrats about his work promoting the Employee Retention Credit and so-called “tribal tax credits.” The job of acting commissioner has since been filled by Douglas O’Donnell, who was deputy commissioner under Werfel. However, O’Donnell abruptly retired as the IRS came under pressure to lay off thousands of employees and share access to confidential taxpayer data. He was replaced by IRS chief operating officer Melanie Krause, who resigned last week after coming under similar pressure to provide taxpayer data to immigration authorities and employees of the Musk-led U.S. DOGE Service. 

Krause had planned to depart later this month under the deferred resignation program at the IRS, under which approximately 22,000 IRS employees have accepted the voluntary buyout offers. But Musk reportedly pushed to have Shapley installed on Tuesday, according to the Times, and he remained working in the commissioner’s office as recently as Friday morning. Meanwhile, plans are underway for further reductions in the IRS workforce of up to 40%, according to the Federal News Network, taking the IRS from approximately 102,000 employees at the beginning of the year to around 60,000 to 70,000 employees.

Continue Reading

Accounting

On the move: EY names San Antonio office MP

Published

on

Carr, Riggs & Ingram appoints CFO and chief legal officer; TSCPA hosts accounting bootcamp; and more news from across the profession.

Continue Reading

Accounting

Tech news: Certinia announces spring release

Published

on


Certinia announces spring release; Intuit acquires tech and experts from fintech Deserve; Paystand launches feature to navigate tariffs; and other accounting tech news and updates.

Continue Reading

Trending