Accounting
Why accounting firms are bleeding talent
Published
1 week agoon
Enjoy complimentary access to top ideas and insights — selected by our editors.
The talent shortage facing the accounting profession is well known at this point, as graduates with accounting majors are deterred by stagnant wages and a lack of education on career paths — while existing accountants leave the field entirely. Amid this identity crisis, firms are starting to look inwards for solutions.
Data from the most recent
But many in the field say the hurdles to becoming a licensed CPA, including the test itself, are simply not worth the payoff.
Read more:
“Tuition costing six figures, 150 credit hours just to sit for the exam and a median salary of $79,880 just isn’t going to get most younger people out of bed in the morning when they can work from their couch making money doing things they’re interested in and have a flexible schedule,” said Erin Andrews, owner of the Vero Beach, Florida-based firm Level Accounting & Advisory.
Andrews highlighted the proliferation of social media personalities and private-equity firms encroaching on the accounting space as “supposed” experts, driving the consumer demand for increased availability and devaluing licenses.
“Being available and offering a great client experience seem to be more important than having letters after your name today,” she said.
Some organizations seeking to address this disparity are developing their own training regimens and partnering with outside trade groups to expand recruitment efforts.
In addition to partnering with the National Association of Black Accountants and Future Business Leaders of America,
The New York-based
Zachary Gordon, a CPA and chairperson of the New York State Society of CPAs’ digital assets committee, said technology isn’t just essential for addressing the immediate effects of the shortage, but is also shaping the evolution of the profession.
“AI will help to complete mindless, repetitive tasks and allow talent to shine with higher-value aspects of an engagement. … Accounting becomes less about commodities like a tax return or financial statements and more about being a trusted advisor providing tangible value to clients,” Gordon said.
Tod McDonald, a CPA and co-founder of Valid8 Financial, agreed with the sentiment, highlighting how today’s artificial intelligence-powered tools allow what was once lengthy data preparation to be completed in hours as opposed to weeks.
Read more:
Outside of wages and upward mobility, the profession’s long hours and general lack of flexibility are driving away younger professionals.
Major firms like Ernst & Young recognize these shifts, and are developing plans to address some of the core issues. The organization’s U.S. firm plans to
“There was a time where working ridiculous hours during busy season and not seeing your family was a badge of honor,” said Dean Sonderegger, general manager of research and learning at Wolters Kluwer Tax and Accounting. “Many younger employees no longer feel this way and are looking for more balance between their work and personal lives … and are attracted to firms that are more flexible.”
Read on to find out more about the depth of the talent shortage and how seasoned advocates for the profession are working to bring future generations of talent into the fold.
AICPA collaborates to help tackle talent shortage
Amid the growing talent shortage facing the profession, the American Institute of CPAs worked with the National Association of State Auditors, Comptrollers and Treasurers to publish a
One of the main disparities highlighted in the report is the differences in accounting and auditing standards between those working in the government and private-sector markets. CPAs working in the public sector often come with specialized expertise in certain areas, but salaries and audit fees aren’t always commensurate with that knowledge.
“We have a talent shortage in accounting that affects business as a whole, and many of the pipeline initiatives the profession is putting in place will help the public sector as well,” Susan Coffey, the AICPA’s CEO of public accounting, said in a statement this month.
Read more:
The top MPs building out the talent pipeline
When it comes to top leaders working to stem the outflow of professionals from the world of accounting, the eight honorees on Accounting Today’s
Public perception, tighter partnerships with colleges and universities, broader education regarding career paths in accounting and more are all areas in which the MP Elite are working to make changes both within their firms and across the profession. These recommendations are designed for deployment right away, or as part of long-term strategies.
“The accounting profession faces a significant challenge in how it’s perceived, particularly by younger generations,” Christopher Geier, chief executive of Sikich, told AT. “To combat this, we need to launch a multitiered education and awareness campaign.”
Read more:
Staffing spotlight shifts from seniority to skill sets
Recruiters are starting to focus less on how long a candidate has been in accounting and more on
At the heart of the trend are a host of factors — a lack of education on career opportunities being one of the most significant.
“Accounting is not a linear profession, and aspiring accountants are often not informed about the various paths they can pursue. … As a result, early-career professionals may struggle to envision the long-term utility of myriad opportunities associated with pursuing accounting and tax as a profession,” said Paul Bryant and Stan Hannah, partners at Plante Moran.
Read more:
The talent shortage creates a proving ground for firms
Fewer and fewer college students are choosing to major in accounting, making those who do a valuable asset to firms of any size. But what can companies do to distinguish themselves from their competitors?
“These successful firms will achieve this by creating a culture that fosters mutual support, offers meaningful career opportunities, promotes team cohesion and ensures both personal and professional fulfillment,” Eric Abati, CEO of San Antonio-based Regional Leader ATKG Advisors, said in an interview with AT’s
Abati represents one perspective of leaders — those focused on changing the tried-and-true corporate culture that is standard throughout the accounting profession — while others focus on career mapping and wage disparities.
Read more:
What will it take to fix the pipeline issue?
Competitive wages, ample preparation for certification exams and a rebranding campaign. These are just a few of the recommendations that experts with the National Pipeline Advisory Group shared for how employers can do their part in addressing the staffing shortage.
“With so many of the themes we uncovered, the solutions lie at the employers’ feet,” Jennifer Wilson, who served as facilitator for the group’s work, told attendees at the AICPA Engage Conference in June. “We’re going to have to make changes. We need to take responsibility as employers for these solutions.”
Salaries were the first up, as data from the group’s report found that only one in nine business majors selected accounting as their major, as the others were able to obtain a higher salary in a more competitive industry.
Read more:
You may like
Accounting
PCAOB releases CAMs guidance for auditors of small firms
Published
5 hours agoon
November 13, 2024The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board is rolling out a new series of staff publications targeted at auditors of small public companies, starting with one on critical audit matters, as board members face the likelihood of a deregulatory emphasis under the incoming Trump administration and probable changes in board composition.
The PCAOB released the first of the new series of staff publications, “
The PCAOB staff is continuing to identify a great many deficiencies related to critical audit matters. CAMs are a relatively new requirement from the PCAOB. A CAM is defined as any matter arising from the audit of the financial statements that was communicated or required to be communicated to the audit committee and that relates to accounts or disclosures that are material to the financial statements; and involved especially challenging, subjective or complex auditor judgment.
This edition of Audit Focus highlights key reminders on determination, communication and documentation of CAMs, along with the PCAOB staff’s perspectives on some of the common deficiencies, such as not accurately describing how a CAM was addressed in the audit, plus good practices that the staff has observed related to CAMs, such as use of practice aids.
PCAOB board members George Botic and Christina Ho discussed the recent inspection findings during a panel discussion Wednesday during Financial Executives International’s Current Financial Reporting Insights conference.
“When you think about where our inspectors see repeated observations, deficiencies, if you will, particularly in Part I.A, which are for the firms not obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence, things like revenue recognition, inventory, allowance for credit losses in the financial sector, areas around business combinations, allowance for allocation of purchase price, things such as that, as well as long-lived assets, goodwill, intangibles, evaluation, those are some of the more frequent areas,” said Botic. “ICFR certainly is one as well in the internal control space. But those areas, those themes, really haven’t changed. Sometimes we’ll see more of one versus another.”
During its inspections last year, the PCAOB saw some improvements at the largest firms, even though audit deficiency rates still appear to be high, with 46% of the engagements reviewed in 2023 having at least one deficiency significant enough to be included in Part I.A of the inspection report, excluding broker-dealer audit inspections, according to a
“There appears to be some improvement in terms of the deficiency rate trend for the largest firms,” said Ho. “It’s probably too soon to tell whether that is going to be the ongoing trend. Also for triennial firms, the spotlight also highlighted the fact that the deficiency rates are not improving.”
She pointed out that financial restatements are another way to look at the situation. “Obviously, the deficiency rate is not the only measurement of audit quality,” said Ho. “We also look at restatements, which I think for many of the preparers and audit committees that I talk to, and even investors, they focus on that metric a lot. The multiple metrics paint a picture.”
Botic sees advantages in having several such metrics. “The audit process is one of the most complex processes, probably in business,” said Botic. “When you think about all the judgments that you all go through for your financial statements and preparing them, then the auditor makes his or her own risk assessment judgments, it’s an incredibly complex process. So I agree, not one metric necessarily is the only metric for sure. We’re inspecting the audit, so our inspectors are looking at what the auditor did or didn’t do, as the case may be, and as part of that, we may identify the accounting was wrong. That is one possibility, as Christina mentioned, the categorization of the reports. But in my view and from my prior life as well, and spending a lot of time in inspections, I actually think that the spread from the inspection deficiency rates for the filers that we looked at compared to the restatement number, I think that’s actually … reflective of the success of our inspection program.”
Ho recently
Accounting Today asked Ho during a press conference after the FEI CFRI session about the political pressure she faced, especially with President-elect Trump’s administration coming in and perhaps replacing PCAOB board members as happened during his first administration as well as the Biden administration.
“Like I said in my LinkedIn post, I’m not a political person,” Ho responded. “When I was at Treasury, I worked under two different administrations as a career person, and I always feel like accounting shouldn’t be political. But obviously, elections have consequences, and I’m not living in a cocoon that I’m not aware of what’s going on. I really do think that it’s in the best interest of the capital markets for political influence to be minimized to technical areas that require expertise, and that’s how I operate, whether I was in Treasury or even at the board here. I often feel like the areas we work in, auditing and accounting, are specialized and require expertise and I hope that the experts can always be allowed to voice their views and also do their job well.”
The PCAOB has been facing
“One of the really important things that regulators should do is to listen,” said Ho. “We should take comments very seriously and we should not rush into adopting standards or rules when we don’t have enough evidence to support the benefits and also the effectiveness of those proposals.”
She acknowledged that the increased risks and responsibilities of auditors, as well as the potential penalties, may be one factor that’s making it harder to attract young people to the accounting and auditing profession.
“I have certainly heard many anecdotal comments about the regulatory environment making the profession less attractive,” said Ho. “I’ve heard from people who talk about how they don’t want to do public company audits because of the inspections, and also our posture on enforcement. If you are not allowed to get indemnified, you know, as an individual, if something happened and there’s in your sanction, certainly people consider that as an increased risk for what they do. I think these things have an impact on the attractiveness of the profession and certainly impact talent. That is some of the anecdotal information I’ve heard. I’ve also heard from smaller firms that they are trying to stay under the 100 number because that will move them into annually, inspected so that they can stay under 100 so they don’t have to be inspected every year. Those kind of comments certainly concern me, because I don’t think this audit marketplace can afford less competition and also less talent. These are things that I think about and I’m concerned about.”
The PCAOB typically inspects each firm either annually or triennially (i.e., once every three years). If a firm provides audit opinions for more than 100 issuers, the PCAOB inspects them annually. If a firm provides audit opinions for 100 or fewer issuers, the PCAOB, in general, inspects them at least every three years.
Ho was also asked about the
“I have a good relationship with the IIA organization, and I actually have been an internal auditor before,” said Ho. “I understand what they do and their values and why it’s important. I certainly think that they play a key role in fostering the trust of the capital markets, because they are in the company. Different data that have been published that the external auditor, they come in and focus on the financial statements and the internal control over financial reporting. Their scope is limited to that, whereas the internal auditors are covering the entire company and the operations and and they have access to much more information and people than external auditors, so they play a key role in facilitating the trust. It looks like they are also focusing a lot on modernizing their standards. They have done that, and then they have been really focusing on AI as well. So I think that it’s important to make sure that all the key players in the financial report ecosystem are working together so that we can collectively ensure the quality of the financial reporting and the audit.”
Accounting Today also asked about the role of artificial intelligence and data analytics programs in auditing and if they could be degrading audit quality without the human element being present.
Ho pointed out that the PCAOB has published a
Accounting
‘Bitcoin Jesus’ fights IRS tax evasion case from Spanish island
Published
6 hours agoon
November 13, 2024To his followers, Roger Ver is known as Bitcoin Jesus, a charismatic advocate of the cryptocurrency that is once again captivating investors with record-breaking gains. But to the Internal Revenue Service, Ver symbolizes a new target in the digital age: a crypto holder suspected of failing to pay taxes after selling tokens.
U.S. prosecutors
Ver, 45, is awaiting a Spanish judge’s
“They don’t like me, and they don’t like my political views, and they just came at me every which way,” Ver told Bloomberg News in an exclusive interview in late October.
Ver, a U.S. expatriate, awaits a Spanish judge’s decision over whether he will be extradited to America to face tax fraud charges.
Ver said the Justice Department has ignored evidence that helps his defense and refutes a central premise by prosecutors — that he intended to cheat the IRS. Rather, he said, he relied on professionals who advised him when IRS policy on taxing crypto sales was unsettled.
“I instructed all my tax attorneys and preparers, ‘We need to do everything perfectly because I don’t want any problem with the IRS at all,”‘ Ver said. “That was their instructions the whole time.”
A Justice Department representative declined to comment.
The seeds of Ver’s legal peril lay in his success as an early crypto investor — long before the latest Bitcoin rally fueled by Donald Trump’s U.S. presidential win. They center on his representations to the IRS and the agency’s reconstruction of his holdings.
Ver grew up in Silicon Valley, founding a computer company called MemoryDealers at the precocious age of 19. He also engaged in tax protests and ran for California’s legislature at 21 as a libertarian.
In 2001, he
Spreading the gospel
When crypto began, he embraced its promise for transferring wealth without government interference. He started buying Bitcoin in 2011 for less than $1, touting it at barbecues, parties and everywhere else. Intense and fast talking, he spread the vision of using crypto to buy a sandwich or even a car. When Bitcoin hit it big, Ver touted its potential from conference stages.
He co-founded Blockchain.com, a crypto company once valued at $14 billion, and was an early investor in payment processor BitPay and digital-asset firm Ripple. When the Bitcoin network underwent a software upgrade he opposed in 2017, Ver broke with the community, switching to a split-off called Bitcoin Cash. He said his current holdings include Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Ether and Zeno.
Despite his notoriety, Ver decided in 2014 to renounce his U.S. citizenship, later becoming a citizen of St. Kitts and Nevis. U.S. citizens who
As he planned to expatriate, prosecutors allege, Ver hid the number and value of Bitcoin he owned and controlled personally and through MemoryDealers and Agilestar, his California-based companies.
The IRS used blockchain analysis to determine that by early 2014, Ver and his companies owned about 131,000 Bitcoin trading between $782 and $960, according to the indictment — more than he reported in tax filings. He’s accused of tax evasion, wire fraud, and filing a false tax return.
Ver worked with a law firm and appraisers on the exit tax, but gave them false or misleading information about his Bitcoin holdings, and an exit tax return filed in 2016 failed to report the Bitcoin he owned personally and underreported the value of his companies, prosecutors charge.
The indictment also alleges Ver “fraudulently misrepresented and concealed” from the IRS the crypto that his companies sold in 2017 for about $240 million.
Ver disputes this characterization, but declined to discuss the indictment further or elaborate on his crypto holdings with Bloomberg.
A website,
In 2022, the U.S. Supreme Court took up a case that didn’t name the parties but matched Ver’s circumstances. The court dropped that case in 2023 without issuing a ruling.
If he’s extradited, Ver’s case would be the first to go to trial on crypto-only tax charges. In February, a Texas man, Frank Ahlgren, was accused of underreporting capital gains from selling $3.7 million in Bitcoin. Ahlgren
Ver, who has more than 700,000 followers on X, spent years under IRS investigation as he traveled the world. In 2021, he posted a satirical
Ver was indicted Feb. 15 under court seal but didn’t learn about it until weeks later, when he was at the Privacy Guardians conference in Barcelona. His
“The bottom kind of fell out of my stomach and I was like, ‘Oh, my God, the U.S. is going to do this to me again,”‘ Ver said.
Back to jail
With his arrest, Ver returned to prison, this time to a two-man cell in Spain. Some inmates incorrectly assumed he was an American spy or undercover cop, he said.
“I didn’t tell anybody in there who I was because I didn’t want to get extorted or have any sort of problems with anybody,” Ver said.
Spain has been a close ally of the U.S. in extradition cases. This year, Spain sent
Ver said he’s spending his days in Mallorca talking to his lawyers on Zoom, practicing Brazilian jiujitsu and entertaining friends visiting from overseas. He’s attended Bitcoin meetups, where he said he was well received.
Ver appeared in an HBO
“I said, ‘Please, if you don’t mind, don’t mention that to anybody else.’ He said, ‘Sure, no problem.’ But he had kind of a sly grin when he said that to me.”
Accounting
Super Micro delays another filing after auditor’s resignation
Published
6 hours agoon
November 13, 2024Super Micro Computer Inc., the troubled server maker whose auditor resigned last month, delayed yet another filing as it continues to search for a new accounting firm.
The company said Wednesday that it can’t file its 10-Q quarterly report for the three months ended Sept. 30 in a timely fashion and will also need more time to prepare its 10-Q for the first quarter of 2025. The firm has already failed to file its annual 10-K report for the period ended June 30.
Super Micro has seen more than $50 billion of its market value wiped out over concerns about its accounting. Earlier this year, a former employee alleged in federal court that the company had sought to overstate its revenue. Short seller Hindenburg Research later referenced those claims in a report, alleging “glaring accounting red flags.” In late September, the firm’s auditor Ernst & Young LLP resigned, citing questions about its client’s commitment to integrity and ethics.
The company’s board had formed a committee to review its internal controls. That panel has finished its investigation based on “initial concerns” raised by EY, Super Micro said in a filing Wednesday, but the committee “has other work that is ongoing.” The firm said it’s “diligently working” to find a new auditor.
Super Micro’s shares were down 2.9% in premarket trading Wednesday. The stock has plunged 82% since peaking in March.
Cisco sees product orders accelerate in the AI era, and its outlook moves higher
Dow shrugs off new inflation data. Bond yields suggest it’s ‘top of mind’ for 2025.
Chinese AI startup Shengshu launches image-to-video tool, rivaling Sora
Are American progressives making themselves sad?
U.S. Beneficial Ownership Information Registry Now Accepting Reports
New 2023 K-1 instructions stir the CAMT pot for partnerships and corporations
Trending
-
Technology1 week ago
How Small and Midsize Businesses Can Harness AI for Growth
-
Personal Finance1 week ago
ETF strategies heading into the U.S. presidential election
-
Blog Post4 days ago
The Essential Practice of Bank and Credit Card Statement Reconciliation
-
Economics6 days ago
Democrats suffer in statehouse races, too
-
Finance6 days ago
China expected to announce highly anticipated fiscal stimulus package
-
Technology2 days ago
AI Use Cases: Retail, Finance & Healthcare Solutions
-
Accounting1 week ago
Art of Accounting: Catch someone doing something good
-
Personal Finance6 days ago
Will you have a lower tax rate in retirement? Maybe not, advisors say