Connect with us

Accounting

Why accounting firms are bleeding talent

Published

on

Complimentary Access Pill

Enjoy complimentary access to top ideas and insights — selected by our editors.

The talent shortage facing the accounting profession is well known at this point, as graduates with accounting majors are deterred by stagnant wages and a lack of education on career paths — while existing accountants leave the field entirely. Amid this identity crisis, firms are starting to look inwards for solutions.

Data from the most recent ADP National Employment Report published this month showed that the service-providing sector added 101,000 jobs in September, 20,000 of which were for roles in professional and business services like accounting and tax preparation. The month before, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1,500 new postings described accounting-related openings.

But many in the field say the hurdles to becoming a licensed CPA, including the test itself, are simply not worth the payoff.

Read more: EY fires staff for ‘cheating’ on training courses

“Tuition costing six figures, 150 credit hours just to sit for the exam and a median salary of $79,880 just isn’t going to get most younger people out of bed in the morning when they can work from their couch making money doing things they’re interested in and have a flexible schedule,” said Erin Andrews, owner of the Vero Beach, Florida-based firm Level Accounting & Advisory.

Andrews highlighted the proliferation of social media personalities and private-equity firms encroaching on the accounting space as “supposed” experts, driving the consumer demand for increased availability and devaluing licenses.

“Being available and offering a great client experience seem to be more important than having letters after your name today,” she said.

Some organizations seeking to address this disparity are developing their own training regimens and partnering with outside trade groups to expand recruitment efforts.

In addition to partnering with the National Association of Black Accountants and Future Business Leaders of America, CliftonLarsonAllen launched an apprenticeship program named CLA Academy this year to prepare them for roles across the company.

The New York-based Whitman Transition Advisors debuted its Talent Solutions Team this month to help clients tackle staffing challenges through services that include full-time and fractional recruitment, outsourced advisory and technology tools.

Zachary Gordon, a CPA and chairperson of the New York State Society of CPAs’ digital assets committee, said technology isn’t just essential for addressing the immediate effects of the shortage, but is also shaping the evolution of the profession.

“AI will help to complete mindless, repetitive tasks and allow talent to shine with higher-value aspects of an engagement. … Accounting becomes less about commodities like a tax return or financial statements and more about being a trusted advisor providing tangible value to clients,” Gordon said.

Tod McDonald, a CPA and co-founder of Valid8 Financial, agreed with the sentiment, highlighting how today’s artificial intelligence-powered tools allow what was once lengthy data preparation to be completed in hours as opposed to weeks.

Read more: Talent scarcity puts renewed focus on AI

Outside of wages and upward mobility, the profession’s long hours and general lack of flexibility are driving away younger professionals.

Major firms like Ernst & Young recognize these shifts, and are developing plans to address some of the core issues. The organization’s U.S. firm plans to allocate roughly $1 billion over the next three years to boost early-career compensation and fund the development of AI-powered audit and tax software.

“There was a time where working ridiculous hours during busy season and not seeing your family was a badge of honor,” said Dean Sonderegger, general manager of research and learning at Wolters Kluwer Tax and Accounting. “Many younger employees no longer feel this way and are looking for more balance between their work and personal lives … and are attracted to firms that are more flexible.”

Read on to find out more about the depth of the talent shortage and how seasoned advocates for the profession are working to bring future generations of talent into the fold.

AICPA collaborates to help tackle talent shortage

The AICPA's Sue Coffey addressing Engage 2023

The AICPA’s Sue Coffey addressing Engage 2023

Amid the growing talent shortage facing the profession, the American Institute of CPAs worked with the National Association of State Auditors, Comptrollers and Treasurers to publish a joint report offering tailored recommendations for creating a strong pipeline of future talent in the public sector.

One of the main disparities highlighted in the report is the differences in accounting and auditing standards between those working in the government and private-sector markets. CPAs working in the public sector often come with specialized expertise in certain areas, but salaries and audit fees aren’t always commensurate with that knowledge.

“We have a talent shortage in accounting that affects business as a whole, and many of the pipeline initiatives the profession is putting in place will help the public sector as well,” Susan Coffey, the AICPA’s CEO of public accounting, said in a statement this month.

Read more: AICPA looks to ease accountant shortage in public sector

The top MPs building out the talent pipeline

Talent shortage puzzle concept

When it comes to top leaders working to stem the outflow of professionals from the world of accounting, the eight honorees on Accounting Today’s 2024 ranking of the MP Elite are practicing what they preach.

Public perception, tighter partnerships with colleges and universities, broader education regarding career paths in accounting and more are all areas in which the MP Elite are working to make changes both within their firms and across the profession. These recommendations are designed for deployment right away, or as part of long-term strategies.

“The accounting profession faces a significant challenge in how it’s perceived, particularly by younger generations,” Christopher Geier, chief executive of Sikich, told AT. “To combat this, we need to launch a multitiered education and awareness campaign.”

Read more: Stacking the pipeline

Staffing spotlight shifts from seniority to skill sets

Hidden Talent

Recruiters are starting to focus less on how long a candidate has been in accounting and more on what skills they bring to the table. But as the pool of available professionals continues shrinking, experts from Southfield, Michigan-based Top 100 Firm Plante Moran weighed in on how other organizations can stay ahead of the curve.

At the heart of the trend are a host of factors — a lack of education on career opportunities being one of the most significant.

“Accounting is not a linear profession, and aspiring accountants are often not informed about the various paths they can pursue. … As a result, early-career professionals may struggle to envision the long-term utility of myriad opportunities associated with pursuing accounting and tax as a profession,” said Paul Bryant and Stan Hannah, partners at Plante Moran. 

Read more: Talent evolution: From years-on-job to agility in action

The talent shortage creates a proving ground for firms

EMPLOYEE-TURNOVER

Fewer and fewer college students are choosing to major in accounting, making those who do a valuable asset to firms of any size. But what can companies do to distinguish themselves from their competitors?

“These successful firms will achieve this by creating a culture that fosters mutual support, offers meaningful career opportunities, promotes team cohesion and ensures both personal and professional fulfillment,” Eric Abati, CEO of San Antonio-based Regional Leader ATKG Advisors, said in an interview with AT’s Daniel Hood. “Simply put: Culture wins.”

Abati represents one perspective of leaders — those focused on changing the tried-and-true corporate culture that is standard throughout the accounting profession — while others focus on career mapping and wage disparities.

Read more: Accounting’s pipeline problem: An opportunity in disguise?

What will it take to fix the pipeline issue?

Businessman Shaking Hand With Female Applicant

Andrey Popov/Andrey Popov – stock.adobe.com

Competitive wages, ample preparation for certification exams and a rebranding campaign. These are just a few of the recommendations that experts with the National Pipeline Advisory Group shared for how employers can do their part in addressing the staffing shortage.

“With so many of the themes we uncovered, the solutions lie at the employers’ feet,” Jennifer Wilson, who served as facilitator for the group’s work, told attendees at the AICPA Engage Conference in June. “We’re going to have to make changes. We need to take responsibility as employers for these solutions.”

Salaries were the first up, as data from the group’s report found that only one in nine business majors selected accounting as their major, as the others were able to obtain a higher salary in a more competitive industry. 

Read more: NPAG: All hands on deck to solve the pipeline problem

Continue Reading

Accounting

IAASB tweaks standards on working with outside experts

Published

on

The International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board is proposing to tailor some of its standards to align with recent additions to the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants’ International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants when it comes to using the work of an external expert.

The proposed narrow-scope amendments involve minor changes to several IAASB standards:

  • ISA 620, Using the Work of an Auditor’s Expert;
  • ISRE 2400 (Revised), Engagements to Review Historical Financial Statements;
  • ISAE 3000 (Revised), Assurance Engagements Other than Audits or Reviews of Historical Financial Information;
  • ISRS 4400 (Revised), Agreed-upon Procedures Engagements.

The IAASB is asking for comments via a digital response template that can be found on the IAASB website by July 24, 2025.

In December 2023, the IESBA approved an exposure draft for proposed revisions to the IESBA’s Code of Ethics related to using the work of an external expert. The proposals included three new sections to the Code of Ethics, including provisions for professional accountants in public practice; professional accountants in business and sustainability assurance practitioners. The IESBA approved the provisions on using the work of an external expert at its December 2024 meeting, establishing an ethical framework to guide accountants and sustainability assurance practitioners in evaluating whether an external expert has the necessary competence, capabilities and objectivity to use their work, as well as provisions on applying the Ethics Code’s conceptual framework when using the work of an outside expert.  

Continue Reading

Accounting

Tariffs will hit low-income Americans harder than richest, report says

Published

on

President Donald Trump’s tariffs would effectively cause a tax increase for low-income families that is more than three times higher than what wealthier Americans would pay, according to an analysis from the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.

The report from the progressive think tank outlined the outcomes for Americans of all backgrounds if the tariffs currently in effect remain in place next year. Those making $28,600 or less would have to spend 6.2% more of their income due to higher prices, while the richest Americans with income of at least $914,900 are expected to spend 1.7% more. Middle-income families making between $55,100 and $94,100 would pay 5% more of their earnings. 

Trump has imposed the steepest U.S. duties in more than a century, including a 145% tariff on many products from China, a 25% rate on most imports from Canada and Mexico, duties on some sectors such as steel and aluminum and a baseline 10% tariff on the rest of the country’s trading partners. He suspended higher, customized tariffs on most countries for 90 days.

Economists have warned that costs from tariff increases would ultimately be passed on to U.S. consumers. And while prices will rise for everyone, lower-income families are expected to lose a larger portion of their budgets because they tend to spend more of their earnings on goods, including food and other necessities, compared to wealthier individuals.

Food prices could rise by 2.6% in the short run due to tariffs, according to an estimate from the Yale Budget Lab. Among all goods impacted, consumers are expected to face the steepest price hikes for clothing at 64%, the report showed. 

The Yale Budget Lab projected that the tariffs would result in a loss of $4,700 a year on average for American households.

Continue Reading

Accounting

At Schellman, AI reshapes a firm’s staffing needs

Published

on

Artificial intelligence is just getting started in the accounting world, but it is already helping firms like technology specialist Schellman do more things with fewer people, allowing the firm to scale back hiring and reduce headcount in certain areas through natural attrition. 

Schellman CEO Avani Desai said there have definitely been some shifts in headcount at the Top 100 Firm, though she stressed it was nothing dramatic, as it mostly reflects natural attrition combined with being more selective with hiring. She said the firm has already made an internal decision to not reduce headcount in force, as that just indicates they didn’t hire properly the first time. 

“It hasn’t been about reducing roles but evolving how we do work, so there wasn’t one specific date where we ‘started’ the reduction. It’s been more case by case. We’ve held back on refilling certain roles when we saw opportunities to streamline, especially with the use of new technologies like AI,” she said. 

One area where the firm has found such opportunities has been in the testing of certain cybersecurity controls, particularly within the SOC framework. The firm examined all the controls it tests on the service side and asked which ones require human judgment or deep expertise. The answer was a lot of them. But for the ones that don’t, AI algorithms have been able to significantly lighten the load. 

“[If] we don’t refill a role, it’s because the need actually has changed, or the process has improved so significantly [that] the workload is lighter or shared across the smarter system. So that’s what’s happening,” said Desai. 

Outside of client services like SOC control testing and reporting, the firm has found efficiencies in administrative functions as well as certain internal operational processes. On the latter point, Desai noted that Schellman’s engineers, including the chief information officer, have been using AI to help develop code, which means they’re not relying as much on outside expertise on the internal service delivery side of things. There are still people in the development process, but their roles are changing: They’re writing less code, and doing more reviewing of code before it gets pushed into production, saving time and creating efficiencies. 

“The best way for me to say this is, to us, this has been intentional. We paused hiring in a few areas where we saw overlaps, where technology was really working,” said Desai.

However, even in an age awash with AI, Schellman acknowledges there are certain jobs that need a human, at least for now. For example, the firm does assessments for the FedRAMP program, which is needed for cloud service providers to contract with certain government agencies. These assessments, even in the most stable of times, can be long and complex engagements, to say nothing of the less predictable nature of the current government. As such, it does not make as much sense to reduce human staff in this area. 

“The way it is right now for us to do FedRAMP engagements, it’s a very manual process. There’s a lot of back and forth between us and a third party, the government, and we don’t see a lot of overall application or technology help… We’re in the federal space and you can imagine, [with] what’s going on right now, there’s a big changing market condition for clients and their pricing pressure,” said Desai. 

As Schellman reduces staff levels in some places, it is increasing them in others. Desai said the firm is actively hiring in certain areas. In particular, it’s adding staff in technical cybersecurity (e.g., penetration testers), the aforementioned FedRAMP engagements, AI assessment (in line with recently becoming an ISO 42001 certification body) and in some client-facing roles like marketing and sales. 

“So, to me, this isn’t about doing more with less … It’s about doing more of the right things with the right people,” said Desai. 

While these moves have resulted in savings, she said that was never really the point, so whatever the firm has saved from staffing efficiencies it has reinvested in its tech stack to build its service line further. When asked for an example, she said the firm would like to focus more on penetration testing by building a SaaS tool for it. While Schellman has a proof of concept developed, she noted it would take a lot of money and time to deploy a full solution — both of which the firm now has more of because of its efficiency moves. 

“What is the ‘why’ behind these decisions? The ‘why’ for us isn’t what I think you traditionally see, which is ‘We need to get profitability high. We need to have less people do more things.’ That’s not what it is like,” said Desai. “I want to be able to focus on quality. And the only way I think I can focus on quality is if my people are not focusing on things that don’t matter … I feel like I’m in a much better place because the smart people that I’ve hired are working on the riskiest and most complicated things.”

Continue Reading

Trending