Connect with us

Personal Finance

How abortion access can impact personal finance: Turnaway Study author

Published

on

Arizona residents rally for abortion rights on April 16, 2024 in Phoenix, Arizona.

Gina Ferazzi | Los Angeles Times | Getty Images

Abortion is an important issue for many voters, especially young women, heading into the November election.

Abortion access is about more than politics, or health care: It’s also a personal finance issue, said Diana Greene Foster, a demographer who studies the effects of unwanted pregnancies on people’s lives.

Foster, a professor at the University of California San Francisco, led The Turnaway Study, a landmark research study on the socioeconomic outcomes for Americans who are “turned away” from abortion. The study tracked 1,000 women over a five-year period ending January 2016. The women in the study had all sought abortions at some point before the study commenced; not all received one.

More from Personal Finance:
How to lower healthcare costs during open enrollment
Ozempic is driving up the cost of your health care
Working moms are still more likely to handle child care

In November, voters in 10 states — Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New York and South Dakota — will choose whether to adopt state ballot measures about abortion access.

Such ballot measures follow a U.S. Supreme Court decision in 2022 that struck down Roe v. Wade, the ruling that had established a constitutional right to abortion five decades earlier.

Nationally, women under age 30 rank abortion as the most important issue to their vote on Election Day, according to the KFF Survey of Women Voters, which polled 649 women from Sept. 12 to Oct. 1. It ranked as the third-most-important issue among women voters of all ages, behind inflation and threats to democracy, according to the KFF poll.

Vice President Harris and Former President Trump spar over abortion

Abortion is among the least-important issues for registered Republicans, according to a Pew Research Center poll of 9,720 U.S. adults conducted Aug. 26 to Sept. 2.

CNBC spoke to Foster about the economics of abortion access and the financial impacts of the end of Roe v. Wade.

The conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity.

Low earners most likely to seek an abortion

Greg Iacurci: Can you describe the population of women that typically seek abortions in the U.S.?

Diana Greene Foster: One good thing about The Turnaway Study is that our demographics closely resemble national demographics on who gets abortions.

More than half are already parenting a child. More than half are in their 20s. A small minority are teenagers, even though lots of people think teenagers are the main recipients.

It’s predominantly people who are low-income. That’s been increasingly the case over time. It’s become disproportionately concentrated among people with the least economic resources.

GI: Why is that?

DGF: I think wealthier people have better access to contraceptives, even after the Obamacare-mandated coverage. Not everyone benefits from that. Not all states participate in that.

[Medical providers] still give contraceptives out. There are 20 states that have laws that say you should be able to get a year’s supply at a time, but almost nowhere is that actually available. The law says you should be able to get it, but you don’t. I led the studies that showed that if you make people go back for resupply every month or three months, as is very commonly done, you’re much more likely to have an unintended pregnancy. The laws have changed, but practice hasn’t changed. Access is not perfect yet.

Also, some people have abortions who have intended pregnancies because something went wrong with their health, with the fetus’ health, with their life circumstances. So even contraceptives aren’t the ultimate solution.

Greater likelihood of poverty and evictions

GI: What are the economic findings of your research?

DGF: When we follow people over time, we see that people who are denied an abortion are more likely to say that their household income is below the federal poverty line. They’re more likely to say that they don’t have enough money to meet basic living needs like food, housing and transportation.

Diana Greene Foster

Courtesy: Diana Greene Foster

Wanting to provide for the kids you already have is a common reason for abortion. We see that the existing children are more likely to be in poverty and in households where there aren’t enough resources if their mom couldn’t get an abortion.

[They’re also] more likely to have evictions, have a larger amount of debt if they’re denied an abortion.

GI: Can we quantify those impacts?

DGF: For example, six months after seeking an abortion, 61% of those denied an abortion were below the poverty line compared to just under half — 45% — of those who received an abortion. The higher odds of being below the [federal poverty line] persisted through four years.

And based on credit reports, we find that women denied abortions experienced significant increases in the amount of debt 30 days or more past due of $1,749.70, a 78% increase relative to their pre-pregnancy [average]. The number of public records, such as bankruptcies, evictions and court judgements, significantly increased for those denied abortions, by 81%.

GI: Why does this happen?

DGF: Having a kid is a massive investment. Deciding to parent a child relies on an amount of social support and housing security and access to health care, and our country isn’t at all set up to provide those things for low-income people.

Why costs are both rising and falling for women

GI: Your study took place at a time when Roe v. Wade was still the law. That’s no longer the case. How do you expect these economic consequences might be impacted?

DGF: In The Turnaway Study, people were denied abortions because they were too far along in pregnancy, but now you can be denied an abortion at any point in pregnancy in something like 13 states. So, it potentially affects a much larger group of people.

But there have been other changes which have to do with resources to help people travel and information about how to order medication abortion pills online. So, it isn’t the case that everyone who wants an abortion is now carrying a pregnancy to term.

There has been a lot of effort to circumvent state laws, and I think The Turnaway Study really reveals why. People understand their circumstances, and they are very motivated to get care, even when their state tries to ban it.

GI: What are the financial impacts some women in those states might encounter?

DGF: I’m actually studying the economic costs of the end of Roe and travel [expense]. Costs went up by $200 for people traveling out of state. People were delayed more than a week.

Under Roe, people could drive to an abortion clinic or get a ride; [after,] they were much more likely to be flying, having to take more modes of transportation. Over half stayed overnight. They traveled an average of 10 hours. That means taking time off work too. So, it dramatically increased the cost for those who traveled to get an abortion.

There are people who ordered pills online who are not [included] in the study. For those people, the cost may have gone down because it’s possible to order pills online for less than $30.

But you have to know about it, and you have to have an address, and you have to have internet, and it takes a level of knowledge to be able to pull that off. There can be a need for follow up medical care, so you have to be able to get that.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Personal Finance

Here’s how to find a tax preparer for the 2025 season

Published

on

Leopatrizi | E+ | Getty Images

Most tax preparers don’t have credentials

There are no federal licensing or competency requirements, and some paid preparers have no training or experience, the report noted. Under current law, the minimum requirement for paid professionals is an IRS-issued preparer tax identification number, or PTIN.

However, certified public accountants, enrolled agents and attorneys — professionals with unlimited representation rights before the IRS — generally pass competency tests and have continuing education requirements.

Free preparation options like Volunteer Income Tax Assistance, or VITA, and Tax Counseling for the Elderly, or TCE, also have competency standards.  

How to vet your tax preparer

Unlike big box preparers, many tax professionals don’t accept walk-in traffic and operate mainly by referral, according to Tom O’Saben, an enrolled agent and director of tax content and government relations at the National Association of Tax Professionals.

“Talk to your friends and associates who have had a good experience with their [tax] professional,” he said. “Reach out to them now to see if they’re taking new clients.”

You should also weigh fee structure and availability outside the traditional tax season, which you may need if issues arise, Young said. “Cost is a big factor, but it shouldn’t be the only basis for your decision.”

Roth conversions on the rise: Here's what to know

The IRS keeps a database of credentialed preparers, including those who participate in the agency’s Annual Filing Season Program, which includes yearly refresher tests and continuing education.

You can check CPA and attorney licenses through state boards. Since the IRS oversees enrolled agents, you can email the agency to check licenses.

Continue Reading

Personal Finance

Do real estate agents have to disclose a death in a house? What to know

Published

on

Matt Champlin | Moment | Getty Images

When a real estate agent works with a prospective homebuyer, they’re required to point out physical or material defects in the property.

A death on the property? It depends on the state where the house is located. In most states, death doesn’t count as a material defect requiring disclosure.

Some homes are considered “stigmatized properties,” or dwellings that have been “psychologically impacted by a past or suspected event on the property, but has no physical impact of any kind,” according to the National Association of Realtors. 

Stigmatizing events include murder, suicide, alleged hauntings or a notorious previous owner, NAR noted. 

Different people interact with stigmatized properties in different ways.

Harrison Beacher

real estate agent and managing partner at Coalition Properties Group in Washington, D.C.

Which states require disclosure of death

Listing agents will have different requirements state-by-state on what to disclose to a buyer. Most states don’t have any death disclosure requirements.

Among those that do, rules can be straightforward and explicitly require prior death to be disclosed to homebuyers. Even those rules may only apply to recent deaths or more stigmatizing events such as murder.

In California, for example, a seller must disclose if someone died in the house within the last three years.

Meanwhile, in Alaska, the listing agent must communicate if any known murders or suicides happened in the last year. South Dakota requires sellers to disclose deaths within the last 12 months.

Regulations will depend on the stigma in question. In New York, a seller doesn’t need to disclose if the house was the site of death or crime. But if a seller has made claims of paranormal activity in the home, they have to inform the buyer of supposed ghosts in the property, experts say.

More from Personal Finance:
Buying a home? Here are some key steps to consider
An insurance provision can help with living expenses after a natural disaster
Gen Zers are willing to buy fixer-upper homes

Often, it falls on the homebuyers to directly ask the agent about the property’s history. States such as Georgia do not require real estate agents or sellers to disclose upfront if the home was the site of a death. But they have to be truthful if a prospective buyer inquires.

Outside of what the disclosure laws are in a specific state, listing agents have a fiduciary responsibility to the sellers, said Harrison Beacher, a real estate agent and managing partner at Coalition Properties Group in Washington, D.C.

“If somebody asks me about it, I can point them towards empirical resources to get answers, but I’m not under any requirements to go into detail,” said Beacher.

Here’s what homebuyers should know about properties that have been stigmatized by murder, suicide, alleged hauntings or notorious prior owners, and how to find more detail about the home’s history.

Who buys stigmatized properties?

Stigmatized homes can be a “turnoff” for homebuyers who believe in ghosts or spirits, said Daryl Fairweather, chief economist at Redfin, an online real estate brokerage firm.

“Some people are spooked away,” said Fairweather, while others might “seek out those homes.”

Nearly three-quarters, 72%, of potential homebuyers said they would buy a “haunted” house for a lower price, according to a new report by Real Estate Witch, a data site owned by Clever Real Estate. The site polled 1,000 U.S. adults in September to discover their views on buying and selling supposedly haunted houses.

Some buyers don’t care what happens in a stigmatized property “if it can get them a discount on price,” Beacher said.

About 43% of polled Americans said they would offer at least $50,000 below market value on a haunted house, according to the Real Estate Witch report.

In 2021, the LaBianca mansion, the home where Leno and Rosemary LaBianca were murdered by Charles Manson’s followers in 1969, sold for $1.875 million. The previous owner, Zak Bagans, a paranormal activity investigator, originally put the house on the market for $2.2 million, but later cut the price to $1.9 million.

“Different people interact with stigmatized properties in different ways,” Beacher said.

How a rare type of mortgage is landing homebuyers a 3% mortgage rate

In 2023, about 67% of would-be buyers said they would buy a supposedly haunted house if it met their wants, like having appealing features, the right location or a more affordable price, according to Zillow.

But buyers should know that “every property has a history,” said Connie Vavra, managing broker of RE/MAX, a real estate brokerage franchise, at Elgin, Illinois.

“We can’t erase the history that’s been done there … That doesn’t mean that you can’t have good energy in there and have [a] good experience living in that home.”

How to find out a home’s history

If you have questions or concerns about a property’s history, the first thing you should do is ask the real estate agent. In some states, real estate agents need to provide truthful information upon a buyer’s request, or at the very least, point you toward the right direction to find out.

Here are two ways to check, experts say:

1. Talk to neighbors and officials

Keep an eye out for the property’s neighbors, experts say. Besides the real estate agent, neighbors can give you first-hand experience of the area, as well as information about the previous homeowners. 

You can also call the county manager where the property is located, said Theresa Payton, a former White House chief information officer who is now the CEO of cybersecurity firm Fortalice Solution.

Ask the county manager’s office about the property you’re considering and if there are any crime records associated with it, she said. 

2. Follow the paper trail

An internet search can turn up details. If police responded to any activity at the house, the event will likely be reported in the newspaper and it would be public record, Payton said.

You can do an advanced search online through newspaper headlines and police reports, as “all that information is free,” she said.

Continue Reading

Personal Finance

28% of credit card users are still paying off last year’s holiday debt

Published

on

Customers visit the Macy’s Herald Square store in New York City on Dec. 17, 2023.

Kena Betancur | Corbis News | Getty Images

For some shoppers, the upcoming holiday season may lead to significant credit card debt. Meanwhile, some people are still paying off debt from last year’s gift buying.

In fact, 28% of shoppers who used credit cards have not paid off the presents they purchased for family and friends last year, according to a recent holiday spending report by NerdWallet. The site polled more than 1,700 adults in September.  

“Between buying gifts and booking peak-season travel, the holidays are an expensive time of year,” said Sara Rathner, NerdWallet’s credit cards expert. “Not only are consumers at risk of getting into credit card debt, but that debt can stick around long after the decorations come down.”

More from Personal Finance:
2 in 5 cardholders have maxed out a credit card or come close
2.5% adjustment to Social Security benefits coming in 2025
‘Fantastic time’ to revisit bonds as interest rates fall

The stakes are higher in 2024 with credit card debt already at $1.14 trillion.

This year, spending between Nov. 1 and Dec. 31 is expected to increase again to a record total of $979.5 billion to $989 billion, according to the National Retail Federation.

Shoppers may spend $1,778 on average, up 8% compared to last year, Deloitte’s holiday retail survey found. Most will lean on plastic: About three-quarters, 74%, of consumers plan to use credit cards to make their purchases, according to NerdWallet.

Meanwhile, credit cards are one of the most-expensive ways to borrow money. The average credit card charges more than 20% — near an all-time high.

How to avoid overspending

“Somehow it’s been programmed into the American consumer, that essentially says ‘I have to spend a lot of money on people I care about,'” said Howard Dvorkin, a certified public accountant and the chairman of Debt.com.

It doesn’t have to be that way, he said.

“There’s no magic wand, we just have to do the hard stuff,” said Candy Valentino, author of “The 9% Edge.” Mostly that means setting a budget and tracking expenses.

Valentino recommends reallocating funds from other areas — by canceling unwanted subscriptions or negotiating down utility costs — to help make room for holiday spending.

“A few hundred dollars here and there really adds up,” she said. That “stash of cash is one way set yourself up so you are not taking on new debt.”

How to save on what you spend

Valentino also advises consumers to start their holiday shopping early to take advantage of early deals and discounts or try pooling funds among family or friends to share the cost of holiday gifts.

Then, curb temptation by staying away from the mall and unsubscribing from emails, opting out of text alerts, turning off push notifications in retail apps and unfollowing brands on social, she said.

“It will lessen your need and desire to spend,” Valentino said.

Ramirez: Actual holiday discounts are closer to 30%, not 50%.

Also consider an investment, such as individual stocks or bonds or a charitable donation, instead of gifts to create a more lasting impression. Making something from scratch, such as cookies, a candle or a sugar scrub, may also prove especially meaningful, Valentino said.

Subscribe to CNBC on YouTube.

Continue Reading

Trending