Accounting
Morningstar report names only one HSA provider high quality
Morningstar’s annual report card for the providers on the menu of so-called “triple-tax-free” health savings accounts is in, and most did not earn very high grades.
First American Bank, Lively, UMB, Associated Bank, NueSynergy, Optum and Bank of America came out “average” or “below average” in covering health costs or being a long-term investment account. Importantly, Morningstar used public data and a survey, so the report noted that it was not evaluating specific employer-offered HSAs that vary based on their size and relationships with providers.
Low interest rates
“Part of it is Fidelity just beating everyone in terms of fees pretty much, and that’s a big advantage,” Carlson said. “They have come down across the board. Just like in other areas of asset management, competition has intensified on the fee side.”
READ MORE:
The
HSAs are often “sub-par regarding interest on cash balances,” said planner Autumn Knutson of Tulsa, Oklahoma-based
“HSAs are a powerful vehicle for tax-advantaged healthcare savings, but most consumers are stuck with whatever provider their employer chooses if they want to benefit from payroll deductions toward their HSA,” Knutson said in an email. “As if the nuances of understanding how to qualify for, contribute to and invest within an HSA were not tricky enough, an additional layer of complexity for HSA providers is within the interface, navigating minimum cash balance requirements and fees for other services or selections.”
HSA assets have soared by a factor of 22 between 2006 and 2023 to $123 billion as the share of workers using employer-sponsored plans that have high-deductible health insurance plans jumped from 7% to 31%. HSAs started in 2003 as an effort “to make high-deductible plans more attractive,” according to the report.
In another finding that’s
The participants “may not be able to meet and maintain the minimum investment account balances most providers require” or have enough left over for stocks and bonds after paying medical bills, the report said. The average American had about $13,500 in healthcare expenses in 2022, according to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services figures cited by Morningstar.
“Plans have gotten better in important ways,” the report said. “Both investment and spending account fees have continued to decline, for example, and investment option quality keeps improving. HSA transparency and ease of use could still improve, though, and costs — particularly investing and custodial fees — could drop further. The process of investigating, signing up for and funding accounts remains complicated. Fewer top providers charge maintenance fees, but some still do — and they often require minimum account balances before participants can invest. Most providers also pay paltry interest rates on spending account balances below relatively lofty levels, even two years after rates began rising.”
READ MORE:
While high-deductible plan participants can use a different HSA provider than the one chosen by their employer, that one is “likely most convenient and financially advantageous” because “your contributions are deducted before Social Security and Medicare taxes,” Knutson noted. More often, the participants will move to an alternate provider once they change employers.
As for the investing side of HSAs — or the lack thereof — “some of the biggest problems I see” in the accounts are savers who are “accruing large balances and not investing the cash amounts at all,” Knutson said.
“This is a function less on the HSA provider and more on investors understanding that funds in an HSA are not invested by default, but rather need to be invested after they are contributed,” she said. “Just as 401(k)’s now have a default investment option to protect investors from having decades of funds accidentally uninvested, an idea for improving HSAs could be to have any excess beyond a planned out-of-pocket max be invested, as this would cover any expenses incurred through health insurance and allow any excess amounts saved into an HSA to be invested for longer term goals.”
Companies and lawmakers “can do more to motivate HSA participants to take advantage of their plans’ investment features,” according to the Morningstar report.
“While employers can automatically enroll employees in employer-sponsored retirement plans, the government has not yet allowed them to do the same for employees who are eligible for HSAs. Automatic enrollment has boosted retirement plan participation,” the report said. “Another barrier to increased HSA investing is that participants sometimes aren’t aware of investment-account options. Providers could simplify the account-opening process and better teach participants both how to transfer between the two account types and about the benefits of long-term investing. Providers that offer better guidance and tools tend to have higher average investment account balances.”
In addition, Morningstar gave advisors, tax pros and their clients some best practices to seek out from their providers when using HSAs. For medical expenses, they should look for “no ongoing maintenance fees,” “competitive interest rates on account balances,” “few or no additional fees” and “FDIC insurance on the spending account.”
When thinking about the long-term investment side of HSAs, they should find providers who have “investment menus that cover core areas and limit overlap and volatile or niche strategies,” “investment options that earn Morningstar Medalist Ratings of bronze or higher,” “low fees” and “no minimum balance in a spending account required before investing.”
READ MORE:
Advisors can guide clients through their HSA decisions with an eye toward the lowest-cost investments and an understanding that even a core bond fund could bring higher return than cash, according to Carlson. One method to lock in some intermediate and longer-term gains would be to set aside the “money you’ll need in the short term,” he said.
“Obviously, health care costs are high and rising, so you do want to make sure that, first and foremost, you’re not taking a lot of risk with money you may need to use immediately or in the short term,” Carlson said. “You want to probably try to separate pools of money.”
Bank job; the magic is gone; not a beautiful day in the Neighborhood; and other highlights of recent tax cases.
Washington, D.C.: CPA Timothy Trifilo has been sentenced to 20 months in prison for making a false statement on a mortgage loan application and for not filing an income tax return.
Trifilo worked in compliance for several large accounting and finance firms and recently was managing director at a tax firm where he specialized in transaction structuring and advisory service, tax compliance and tax due diligence.
For a decade, he did not file federal income tax returns nor pay taxes owed despite earning more than $7.7 million during that time. He caused a tax loss to the IRS of more than $2 million.
In February 2023, Trifilo sought to obtain a $1.36 million bank-financed loan to purchase a home in D.C. and was working with a mortgage company. After the company told him that the bank would not approve the loan without copies of his filed returns, Trifilo provided fabricated documents to make it appear as if he had filed federal returns for 2020 and 2021. On these returns and other documents, Trifilo listed a former colleague as the individual who prepared the returns and uploaded them for filing with the IRS. This individual did not prepare the returns, has never prepared returns for Trifilo and did not authorize Trifilo to use his name on the returns and other documents.
The bank approved the loan and Trifilo purchased the home.
Trifilo, who previously
New York: Tax preparer Rafael Alvarez, 61, of Cortland Manor, New York, has been sentenced to four years in prison in connection with a decade-long, $145-million tax fraud.
Alvarez, a.k.a. “the Magician,” who
Alvarez both prepared returns for clients and recruited, supervised and directed other personnel who in turn prepared returns. He oversaw what authorities called “a sweeping fraudulent scheme” where he and his employees submitted false information on clients’ returns. This information included, among other things, bogus itemized tax deductions, made-up capital losses, phony business expenses and fraudulent tax credits.
Alvarez recruited to ATAX and personally trained “impressionable, easily intimidated” workers. When some employees questioned Alvarez about his fraudulent tax prep, he threatened these employees about reporting his scheme.
He deprived the IRS of $145 million in tax revenue.
He was also sentenced to three years of supervised release and ordered to pay the IRS $145 million in restitution and forfeit more than $11.84 million.
Philadelphia: Tax preparer James J. Sirleaf, 65, of Darby, Pennsylvania, has pleaded guilty to a multiyear scheme to help clients file false income tax returns to fraudulently increase their refunds, as well as to filing false personal income tax returns for himself.
Sirleaf, who previously pleaded guilty, was the sole owner and operator of Metro Financial Services; he prepared false and fraudulent 1040s for clients for at least tax years 2016 through 2019. On the returns he included false deductions, business expenses and dependent information.
He also filed false returns for himself for tax years 2017 through 2019, failing to fully report his income.
Sirleaf caused a tax loss to the IRS of $219,622.
Sentencing is Sept. 3.
Summerfield, North Carolina: William Lamar Rhew III has pleaded guilty to wire fraud, money laundering, securities fraud, tax evasion and failure to file returns in connection with a $20 million Ponzi scheme.
From November 2017 to December 2023, Rhew defrauded at least 117 investors of at least $24 million. He induced victims to invest with his company, Chadley Capital, which would allegedly buy accounts receivable at a discount, sell them for a profit and provide consistently high rates of return. Rhew touted the company’s increasing deal flow and underwriting standards and claimed $300 million in transactions in 2023, consistent returns exceeding 20% per year and nearly 74% total growth over 24 months.
All Rhew’s representations were false. Instead of investing victims’ funds, Rhew used the money on personal expenses, including the purchases of a boat, a beach house and luxury cars, and to make “interest” and “withdrawal” payments to other victim-investors.
For 2018 through 2022, Rhew willfully failed to report nearly $9 million in income to the IRS.
He has agreed to pay almost $14.9 in restitution to the victims and $3,056,936 to the IRS.
Sentencing is Aug. 22. Rhew faces up to 20 years in prison, supervised release of up to three years and monetary penalties.
Miami: In related cases, three tax preparers have pleaded guilty to tax crimes connected to a scheme to prepare false returns.
Franklin Carter Jr., of Sanford, Florida, pleaded guilty to conspiring to defraud the U.S. and to not filing returns. Jonathan Carrillo, of St. Cloud, Florida, pleaded guilty to conspiring to defraud the U.S. and assisting in the preparation of false returns.
Diandre Mentor has pleaded guilty to conspiring to defraud the United States by filing false returns for clients.
From 2016 to 2020, Carter and Carrillo owned and operated Neighborhood Advance Tax, a tax prep business with a dozen offices throughout Florida. Mentor worked there between January 2017 and 2019. The conspirators inflated client refunds by fabricated deductions and held periodic training to teach Neighborhood employees how to prepare fraudulent returns.
In 2020, Mentor and his co-conspirators also started Smart Tax & Finance, which expanded to 12 franchise locations throughout South and Central Florida. The next year, Carter, Carrillo and the co-conspirators started Taxmates, which operated out of the same offices that Neighborhood had used. Both firms prepared false returns for clients; many of those returns included false deductions.
The three also continued to teach franchise owners and employees how to prepare false returns for clients. In addition, Carter did not file personal tax returns for 2019 through 2021.
Carter and Carrillo caused a tax loss to the IRS exceeding $12 million. Mentor caused a tax loss to the IRS totaling $3,090,077.
Several co-conspirators have also pleaded guilty, including Abryle de la Cruz, Emmanuel Almonor, Adon Hemley and Isaiah Hayes.
Carter and Carrillo each face up to five years in prison for the conspiracy charge. Carter faces up to a year for each failure to file a return charge; Carillo faces a maximum of three years for each charge of assisting in the preparation of a false return; Mentor faces up to five years in prison. All three also face a period of supervised release, restitution and monetary penalties.
Hourly earnings growth for small business employees dropped to a four-year low at 2.77% in May, while job growth was flat, according to payroll company Paychex.
The
“There seems to be a very limited amount of dynamism in small businesses right now,” said Frank Fiorille, vice president of risk management, compliance and data analytics at Paychex. “We’re not seeing blockbuster or torrid hiring, but we’re also not seeing major layoffs either. They’re in a frozen state. They don’t want to take any risks.”
The Midwest has represented the strongest region for small business employment growth for the past year, while the West continues to lag all regions and reported an index level below 100 on Paychex’s Small Business Jobs Index for the 14th consecutive month in May.
“The Midwest is doing well, and the coasts are lagging a little bit,” said Fiorille.
Construction dropped 0.68 percentage points to a jobs index of 99.69 in May, marking its lowest level since March 2021. Job growth in the leisure and hospitality industry remained in last place among sectors for the fourth month in a row at 98.18 in May.
Uncertainty over tariffs and the massive tax bill in Congress seem to be holding back small businesses, and accountants should keep a close eye on developments to advise their small business clients. “That’s the ballgame right now for everybody to watch,” said Fiorille.
Tesla Inc.’s shares sank as Elon Musk and President Donald Trump’s simmering feud devolved into a public war of words between two of the world’s most powerful people.
Trump on Thursday said he was “very disappointed” by the Tesla chief executive officer’s criticism of the president’s signature tax policy bill. Musk fired back in several social media posts, saying in one that “without me, Trump would have lost the election.”
The president later floated terminating federal contracts and subsidies extended to Musk’s companies and said that he had asked the Tesla and SpaceX leader to leave his administration, which Musk said was a “lie.”
Tesla’s shares dropped 14% on Thursday in New York, the stock’s biggest decline since March 10. The rout erased about $150 billion from the electric-vehicle maker’s market value.
The spectacle of the world’s richest person and the leader of the free world lobbing insults toward one another on social media marks a stunning breakup of a once formidable political alliance.
Musk spent more than $250 million to help secure Trump’s return to the White House. Trump in turn deputized Musk to lead a sweeping effort to slash government spending and reshape the federal bureaucracy before the mercurial billionaire stepped back from that role last week.
At the same time, policies advanced by Trump and Republican lawmakers put billions of dollars at risk for Tesla, by far Musk’s largest business.
Trump’s massive tax bill would largely eliminate a credit worth as much as $7,500 for buyers of some Tesla models and other electric vehicles by the end of this year, seven years ahead of schedule. That would translate to a roughly $1.2 billion hit to Tesla’s full-year profit, according to JPMorgan analysts.
After leaving his formal advisory role in the White House last week, Musk has been on a mission to block the president’s signature tax bill that he described as a “disgusting abomination.” The world’s richest person has been lobbying Republican lawmakers — including making a
False, this bill was never shown to me even once and was passed in the dead of night so fast that almost no one in Congress could even read it! https://t.co/V4ztekqd4g
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) June 5, 2025
Separate legislation
Taken together, those measures threaten roughly half of the more than $6 billion in earnings before interest and taxes that Wall Street expects Tesla to post this year, analysts led by Ryan Brinkman said in a May 30 report.
Tesla didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.
The House-passed tax bill would aggressively phase-out tax credits for the production of clean electricity, and other sources years earlier than scheduled. It also includes stringent restrictions on the use of Chinese components and materials that analysts said would render the credits useless and limits the ability of companies to sell the tax credits to third parties.
Abruptly ending the energy tax credits would threaten America’s energy independence and the reliability of our grid – we urge the senate to enact legislation with a sensible wind down of 25D and 48e. This will ensure continued speedy deployment of over 60 GW capacity per year to…
— Tesla Energy (@teslaenergy) May 29, 2025
Tesla’s division focused on solar systems and batteries separately criticized the Republican bill for gutting clean energy tax credits, saying that “abruptly ending” the incentives would threaten U.S. energy independence and the reliability of the power grid.
The clean energy and EV policies under threat were largely enacted as part of former President Joe Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act. The law was designed to encourage companies to build a domestic supply chain for clean energy and electric vehicles, giving companies more money if they produce more batteries and EVs in the U.S. Tesla has a broad domestic footprint, including car factories in Texas and California, a lithium refinery and battery plants.
With those Biden-era policies in place, U.S. EV sales rose 7.3% to a record 1.3 million vehicles last year, according to Cox Automotive data.
Tax Fraud Blotter: Prep perps
Small business wage growth slowed in May
Tesla has $1.2B at risk from EV credits cut in Trump tax bill
New 2023 K-1 instructions stir the CAMT pot for partnerships and corporations
The Essential Practice of Bank and Credit Card Statement Reconciliation
Are American progressives making themselves sad?
-
Blog Post5 days agoCommon Bookkeeping Challenges and Solutions for Small Businesses
-
Economics1 week agoElon Musk says Trump’s spending bill undermines the work DOGE has been doing
-
Economics1 week agoHow young voters helped to put Trump in the White House
-
Personal Finance1 week agoHarvard, Trump international enrollment battle affects college applicants
-
Accounting1 week agoHighest paid jobs in corporate accounting
-
Economics6 days agoWhy the president must not be lexicographer-in-chief
-
Personal Finance1 week agoCrypto in 401(k) plans: Trump administration eases rules
-
Finance1 week agoVail Resorts, GameStop and more