Connect with us

Accounting

PCAOB sees improvements in largest audit firms

Published

on

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board’s inspection staff found noticeable improvements in the deficiency rates of the six largest global auditing firms, according to a report Monday.

In 2024, the PCAOB observed a tangible decrease in Part I.A deficiency rates, on average, across all inspected firms, as well as a substantial improvement, in the aggregate, among the largest firms it inspects annually. The improvement follows increased efforts by the PCAOB to encourage firms to reverse the trend of rising deficiency rates following the pandemic. 

“We challenged the audit profession to do better for America’s investors, and these significant improvements demonstrate real progress in protecting investors,” said PCAOB chair Erica Williams in a statement. “Still, our work is far from over, and I urge the audit profession to build on this momentum.”

For all inspected firms, the aggregate Part I.A deficiency rate decreased to 39% in 2024, down from 46% in 2023. For the Big Four U.S. firms (Deloitte, EY, KPMG and PwC), which as of Dec. 31, 2024, collectively audit about 80% of the market capitalization of public companies, the aggregate Part I.A deficiency rate decreased to 20% in 2024, down from 26% in 2023.

The aggregate Part I.A deficiency rate for the six U.S. global network firms (BDO USA, Deloitte, EY, Grant Thornton, KPMG and PwC) decreased to 26% in 2024, from 34% in 2023.

Results at the eight annually inspected U.S. non-affiliated firms held steady, decreasing to 52% in the aggregate in 2024, compared to 53% in 2023 (when the eight inspected firms were Marcum, RSM US, Crowe, Withum, Moss Adams, Baker Tilly US, B F Borgers and Cohen & Company, Ltd., though BF Borgers was suspended last year and Marcum was acquired by CBIZ). While the same firms are not inspected year-to-year, the PCAOB saw improvements at the non-affiliated firms and global network triennially inspected firms. Aggregate deficiency rates at NAF triennially inspected firms decreased from 67% in 2023 to 61% in 2024, and GNF triennially inspected firms decreased from 35% in 2023 to 26% in 2024.

Williams has called on firms to improve their audit quality since she became chair of the PCAOB in 2022, and the PCAOB has been focusing on encouraging auditing firms to address their high deficiency rates coming out of the pandemic. Some of the initiatives include publishing more information, resources and tools to help firms improve their audit quality; increasing transparency; engaging regularly with audit firms; providing focused support to smaller firms; publishing implementation guidance for new PCAOB standards; prioritizing guidance and communication regarding remediation submissions for quality control deficiencies; engaging directly and regularly with U.S. audit committees; and increasing the PCAOB’s focus on the effect of firm culture on audit quality.

The PCAOB began seeing deficiency rates leveling off at the largest firms last year when it released its 2023 inspection results for them. On Monday, the PCAOB released separate inspection reports for the six largest firms. 

At BDO USA, P.C, 18 of the 30 audits reviewed in 2024 were included in Part I.A of the report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 60% deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies mainly related to BDO’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue and related accounts, goodwill and intangible assets, and business combinations. However, that represented an improvement over BDO USA’s 2023 results, when 25 of the 29 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2023 were included in Part I.A, an 86% Part I.A deficiency rate.

At Deloitte & Touche LLP, nine of the 63 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2024 were included in Part I.A of the report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, for a 14% Part I.A deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies mainly related to Deloitte’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue, allowance for credit losses, and leases. That too was an improvement for Deloitte, where in its 2023 report, 12 of the 56 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2023 were included in Part I.A of the report, translating into a 21% Part I.A audit deficiency rate.

At Ernst & Young LLP, 18 of the 64 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2024 were included in Part I.A of this report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 28% Part I.A deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies primarily related to EY’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue and related accounts, inventory and long-lived assets. That again was an improvement over 2023’s inspection report for EY, when 22 of the 59 audits we reviewed in 2023 are included in Part I.A, for a 37% deficiency rate.

At Grant Thornton LLP, 13 of the 27 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2024 were included in Part I.A of this report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 48% Part IA deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies primarily related to the firm’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue and related accounts and inventory. While a 48% deficiency rate may seem high, it was better than the 54% rate on the 2023 inspection report for GT, when 15 of the 28 audits reviewed in 2023 were included in Part I.A.

For KPMG LLP, 13 of the 64 audits reviewed in 2024 were included in Part I.A of its report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 20% Part I.A deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies mainly related to the firm’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue and related accounts and allowance for credit losses. That too was an improvement over the 15 of 58 audits reviewed in 2023 that were included in Part I.A of the 2023 report on KPMG, a 26% Part I.A deficiency rate.

For PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 10 of the 64 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2024 were included in Part I.A of the report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 16% Part I.A deficiency rate. The identified deficiencies primarily related to the firm’s testing of controls over and/or substantive testing of revenue and related accounts and the allowance for credit losses. That was comparable to the 2023 report for PwC, when 10 of the 57 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2023 were included in Part I.A of the report, an 18% Part I.A deficiency rate.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Accounting

House passes tax administration bills

Published

on

The House unanimously passed four bipartisan bills Tuesday concerning taxes and the Internal Revenue Service that were all endorsed this week by the American Institute of CPAs, and passed two others as well.

  • H.R. 1152, the Electronic Filing and Payment Fairness Act, sponsored by Rep. Darin LaHood, R-Illinois, Suzan Delbene, D-Washington, Randy Feenstra, R-Iowa, Brad Schneider, D-Illinois, Brian Fitzpatrick, R-Pennsylvania and Jimmy Panetta, D-California. The bill would apply the “mailbox rule” to electronically submitted tax returns and payments to allow the IRS to record payments and documents submitted to the IRS electronically on the day the payments or documents are submitted instead of when they are received or reviewed at a later date. The AICPA believes this would offer clarity and simplification to the payment and document submission process while protecting taxpayers from undue penalties.
  • H.R. 998, the Internal Revenue Service Math and Taxpayer Help Act, sponsored by Rep. Randy Feenstra, R-Iowa, and Brad Schneider, D-Illinois, which would require notices describing a mathematical or clerical error to be made in plain language, and require the Treasury to provide additional procedures for requesting an abatement of a math or clerical error adjustment, including by telephone or in person, among other provisions.
  • H.R. 517, the Filing Relief for Natural Disasters Act, sponsored by Rep. David Kustoff, R-Tennessee, and Judy Chu, D-California. The process of receiving tax relief from the IRS following a natural disaster typically must follow a federal disaster declaration, which can often come weeks after a state disaster declaration. The bill would provide the IRS with authority to grant tax relief once the governor of a state declares either a disaster or a state of emergency and expand the mandatory federal filing extension under Section 7508(d) of the Tax Code from 60 days to 120 days, providing taxpayers with more time to file tax returns after a disaster.
  • H.R. 1491, the Disaster related Extension of Deadlines Act, sponsored by Rep. Gregory Murphy, R-North Carolina, and Jimmy Panetta, D-California, would extend the amount of time disaster victims would have to file for a tax refund or credit (i.e., the lookback period) by the amount of time afforded pursuant to a disaster relief postponement period for taxpayers affected by major disasters. This legislative solution would place taxpayers on equal footing as taxpayers not impacted by major disasters and would afford greater clarity and certainty to taxpayers and tax practitioners regarding this lookback period.

“The AICPA has long supported these proposals and will continue to work to advance comprehensive legislation that enhances IRS operations and improves the taxpayer experience,” said Melanie Lauridsen, vice president of tax policy and advocacy for the AICPA, in a statement Tuesday. “We are pleased to work closely with each of these Representatives on common-sense reforms that will benefit taxpayers, tax practitioners and tax administration and we’re encouraged by their passage in the House. We look forward to continuing to work with Congress to improve the taxpayer experience.”

The bills were also included in a recent Senate discussion draft aimed at improving tax administration at the IRS that are strongly supported by the AICPA.

The House also passed two other tax-related bills Tuesday that weren’t endorsed in the recent AICPA letter. 

  • H.R. 1155, Recovery of Stolen Checks Act, sponsored by Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, R-New York, would require the IRS to create a process for taxpayers to request a replacement via direct deposit for a stolen paper check. If a check is determined to be stolen or lost, and not cashed, a taxpayer will receive a replacement check once the original check is cancelled, but many taxpayers are having their replacement checks stolen as well. Taxpayers who have a check stolen are then unable to request that the replacement check be sent via direct deposit. The bill would require the Treasury to establish processes and procedures under which taxpayers, who are otherwise eligible to receive an amount by paper check in replacement of a lost or stolen paper check, may elect to receive such amount by direct deposit.
  • H.R. 997, National Taxpayer Advocate Enhancement Act, sponsored by Rep. Randy Feenstra, R-Iowa, would prevent IRS interference with National Taxpayer Advocate personnel by granting the NTA responsibility for its attorneys. In advocating for taxpayer rights, the National Taxpayer Advocate often requires independent legal advice. But currently, the staff members hired by the National Taxpayer Advocate are accountable to internal IRS counsel, not the Taxpayer Advocate, creating a potential conflict of interest to the detriment of taxpayers. The bill would authorize the National Taxpayer Advocate to hire attorneys who report directly to her, helping establish independence from the IRS. 

House  Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jason Smith, R-Missouri, applauded the bipartisan House passage of the various bills, which had been unanimously passed by the committee.

“President Trump was elected on the promise of finally making the government work better for working people,” Smith said in a statement Tuesday. “This bipartisan legislation helps fulfill that mandate and makes improvements to tax administration that will make it easier for the American people to file their taxes. Those who are rebuilding after a natural disaster particularly need help filing taxes, which is why this set of bills lightens the load for taxpayers in communities struck by a hurricane, tornado or some other disaster. With Tax Day just a few days away, we must look for common-sense, bipartisan ways to make filing taxes less of a hassle.”

Continue Reading

Accounting

In the blogs: Many hats

Published

on

Teaching fraud; easement settlement offers; new blog on the block; and other highlights from our favorite tax bloggers.

Many hats

  • Taxbuzz (https://www.taxbuzz.com/blog): There’s sure an “I” in this “teamwork:” What to know about potential IRS and ICE collaboration.
  • Tax Vox (https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox): How IRS data would likely be unhelpful validating SNAP eligibility.
  • Yeo & Yeo (https://www.yeoandyeo.com/resources): How financial benchmarking (including involving taxes) can help business clients see trends, pinpoint areas for improvement and forecast future performance.
  • Integritas3 (https://www.integritas3.com/blog): One way to take a bite out of crime, according to this instructor blogger: Teach grad students how to detect, investigate and prevent financial fraud.
  • HBK (https://hbkcpa.com/insights/): Verifying income, fairly distributing property, digging the soon-to-be-ex’s assets out of the back of the dark, dark closet: How forensic accounting has emerged as a crucial element in divorces.

Standing out

Genuine intelligence

  • AICPA & CIMA Insights (https://www.aicpa-cima.com/blog): How artificial intelligence and other tech is “Reshaping Finance,” according to this podcast. Didem Un Ates, CEO of a U.K.-based company offering AI advisory services, tackles the topic.
  • Taxjar (https:/www.taxjar.com/resources/blog): How AI and automation can help even the knottiest sales tax obligations and problems.
  • Dean Dorton (https://deandorton.com/insights/): Favorite opening of the week: “The madness doesn’t just happen on college basketball courts — it also happens when your finance team is stuck using a legacy on-premises accounting system.”
  • Canopy (https://www.getcanopy.com/blog): Top client portals for accounting firms in 2025.
  • Mauled Again (https://mauledagain.blogspot.com/): Despite what Facebook claims, dependents have to be human.

New to us

  • Berkowitz Pollack Brant (https://www.bpbcpa.com/articles-press-releases/): This Florida firm offers a variety of services to many industries and has a good, wide-ranging blog. Recent topics include the BE-10, nexus and state and local tax obligations, IRS cuts and what to know about the possible bonus depreciation phase out. Welcome!

Continue Reading

Accounting

Is gen AI really a SOX gamechanger?

Published

on


By streamlining tasks such as risk assessment, control testing, and reporting, gen AI has the potential to increase efficiency across the entire SOX lifecycle.

Continue Reading

Trending