Accounting
CTA and BOI filing uncertainty continues
The saga of the Corporate Transparency Act and its beneficial ownership information reporting requirement goes on.
When the District Court for the Northern District of Alabama ruled that the CTA was unconstitutional on March 1, 2024, it specified that the ruling only applied to the 65,000 members of the plaintiff organization, the National Small Business Association.
But on Dec. 3, another court, the District Court for the Eastern District of Texas,
Picasa/rrodrickbeiler – Fotolia
Beginning Jan. 1, 2024, the CTA imposed a requirement to file beneficial ownership information with the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FinCEN. Existing companies were required to file within the year 2024, while a new company started during 2024 would have 30 days (temporarily extended to 90 days for 2024 only) to file. An estimated 32.6 million filings were expected during 2024, with five to six million expected each following year. The penalty for failure to comply is $500, with a cap of $10,000.
A beneficial owner is one who directly or indirectly exercises substantial control over the reporting entity, or who directly or indirectly owns or controls 25% or more of the ownership interests of the reporting entity.
“We always thought that a delay was necessary in the filing requirement,” said Roger Harris, president of Padgett Business Services. “That’s because of issues with the 30-day rule and lack of guidance on substantial ownership.”
“We’re telling our people to continue to gather the information necessary to file the report, but to inform clients of where we are regarding the court injunction,” he continued. “We will wait until we get further information from FinCEN and DOJ before we file a report unless the client tells us to go ahead and file. What I hope we hear is that FinCEN believes it will take too long to resolve all the court cases and the outstanding issues about how the current program is being implemented, and will extend the deadline for one year to Jan. 12, 2026.”
“The problem with the order is that it doesn’t talk about any remedies about what will happen once the injunction is lifted or an appellate court says it was wrongly decided,” said attorney Michael Chua. “It doesn’t say that the deadline is automatically extended for one year if the injunction disappears. Technically speaking, those deadlines are still effective. That’s the biggest concern at this point, since it doesn’t provide any remedies — it’s kind of a head-scratcher.”
As of right now, there is no obligation or duty to file, observed Earl Melamed, a partner and head of the CTA Working Group at law firm Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg.
But the penalties are onerous and are likely to catch people unaware, he said, so companies may not want to ignore the requirement entirely.
“We suggest that our clients can pause from any filing that they otherwise might make, but that they should continue to assemble the information so that they are ready to file,” said Melamed. “The requirement can be reimposed at any date — the Texas district court did not decide that the CTA was unconstitutional, they merely said that it was ‘likely’ to be found to be unconstitutional. The appellate court could lift the injunction but say that the deadlines are extended for a year; they could provide more time to file but they don’t have to.”
Melamed believes the DOJ will fight very hard to have the injunction lifted. But given the fact there are a number of cases before different courts around the country seeking to overturn the CTA on constitutional grounds, the question may eventually go before the Supreme Court.
“If there are two conflicting rulings, that’s the ticket to the Supreme Court,” he said.
The Securities and Exchange Commission today
The budget totals $399.7 million, which funds 945 positions. The accounting support fee totals $374.9 million, comprising $346.1 million for public company issuers and $28.8 million for registered broker dealers.
The 2025 budget is a 3.8% increase from this year’s budget of
“Well-functioning financial markets are built on trust,” SEC Chair Gary Gensler said in a
“While the 2025 budget assumes a necessary increase in the ASF overall, we anticipate the smallest billable issuers will see no increase, while the median difference per bill for issuers will likely be only $100, “PCAOB chair Erica Williams said in a statement.
Williams added, “This budget enables us to both provide our staff with competitive compensation that acknowledges their extraordinary work on behalf of investors and retain them, as well as attract new, expert talent to help us meet our investor-protection mission.”
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 provides the SEC with oversight responsibility over the PCAOB, including reviewing and approving the PCAOB’s annual budget and accounting support fee.
Patrick Mouzawak/Bloomberg
Manufacturing Digital highlighted some of the most innovative cloud ERP companies in 2024. Examples include Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central for its comprehensive features and integration with Microsoft applications, while
Why this is important for your firm and clients: If your clients are small businesses using small-business accounting software, and they grow, then they’ll find themselves in need of a more enterprise, scalable platform. If they’re manufacturers, their needs will be that much more unique. This is a great list of current platforms specifically focused on midsized manufacturers that need to address standard and job costing, bills of materials, process manufacturing, ordering, inventory management and other challenges for this industry.
Accounting Today has issued a call for submissions for its 2025 Top New Products report.
The report will recognize the best new and significantly improved products aimed at tax and accounting professionals, as judged by the editors of Accounting Today.
Products for consideration must be designed for the tax and accounting profession; must have been released no earlier than January 2024; and must be currently available (i.e., not in beta testing) in the U.S. market.
Submissions must include:
- Release date;
- Pricing;
- A website URL and/or phone number for customer contact;
- 200 words or less describing the product’s functionality and its relevance to the tax and accounting profession; and
- A digital image or logo for the product, if available (images can be in JPG, EPS or TIFF format, at 300 dpi or higher).
We will accept up to three submissions per vendor, or three per major division of a vendor.
Submissions may be sent by email to our technology editor, Chris Gaetano, at
For additional questions about eligibility, submissions, etc., email
The Fed’s dot plot shows only two rate cuts in 2025, fewer than previously projected
SEC approves $399M PCAOB budget, $346M accounting support fee
What that means for you
New 2023 K-1 instructions stir the CAMT pot for partnerships and corporations
Are American progressives making themselves sad?
U.S. Beneficial Ownership Information Registry Now Accepting Reports
-
Finance1 week agoStocks making the biggest moves after hours: ORCL, AI, MTN, PL
-
Accounting1 week agoReplacing mortgage deduction may boost homeownership
-
Personal Finance1 week agoThe Fed cut interest rates but some credit card APRs haven’t gone down
-
Accounting1 week agoIt’s time to get your WISP in order
-
Accounting1 week agoPCAOB staff report outlines 2025 inspection priorities
-
Accounting1 week agoBig changes expected at SEC under new chair Paul Atkins
-
Accounting1 week agoCanada pressured to respond to Trump’s tax cut regime
-
Leaders1 week agoRishi Sunak, The politic and the Successful Businessman